TBL2 IDP Scoring - VOTE #2

[Football Buddah]

The prevoius vote was 6-5-4... pretty close, but at least that tells me that we have a vote of 11-4 in favor of making some sort of change. As such, I would like for you to vote (again) on WHICH of the two changes you'd prefer to see.

This poll will be up for 1 week. Once we have a majority vote on which one of these to go ahead with - I will post the options, depending on which one wins.

Thanks.

[Orca]

Buddah, could you post exactly what the scoring and line up changes will be in this poll as well.

[Football Buddah]

I was hoping that once we made a decision on which direction to go - we could vote on the details of the changes.


some ideas though have been:

Scoring changes
* Reduce tackles for LB's only from 3 point for every 2 tackles - to 1 point for every 1 tackle.

* Increase scoring for DL's and DB's only from 3 point for every 2 tackles - to 2 points for every 1 tackle.


Lineup changes
* Limit the current IDP flex position to DL or DB only, so that you could only start 1 LB.
(example: 2 DL, 1 LB, 1 DB... or 1 DL, 1 LB, 2 DB)

* Add another IDP flex, for a total of 5 starters, but limit the # of IDP starters to 2 per postion.
(example: 1 DL, 2 LB, 2 DB... or 2 DL, 2 LB, 1 DB... or 2 DL, 1 LB, 2 DB.)



All of the above are merely suggestions though. I'm open for any others, and depending on which option wins from the above poll, we can vote on what the specific change can be.

[Orca]

May 30, 2008 21:18:05 GMT -5 Football Buddah said:

* Add another IDP flex, for a total of 5 starters, but limit the # of IDP starters to 2 per postion.
(example: 1 DL, 2 LB, 2 DB... or 2 DL, 2 LB, 1 DB... or 2 DL, 1 LB, 2 DB.)

I wouldn't be a fan of this set up.

[Football Buddah]

11-2 in favor of a scoring change.

Ok, I'm open for any suggestions. So far, I only have 2:

* Reduce tackles for LB's only from 3 point for every 2 tackles - to 1 point for every 1 tackle.

* Increase scoring for DL's and DB's only from 3 point for every 2 tackles - to 2 points for every 1 tackle.

Any others? Let me know and I will post a new Poll.

[Orca]

can you just enter these figures into the MFL rules and see where they stack up? I can then save each scoring scenario out as a PDF and we can compare them side by side.

[Football Buddah]

I already did that. Here's the summary:

thebigleague.proboards18.com/index.cgi?board=changes&action=display&thread=1064

And if you want to see it in Excel format (with all the players and their points) - go to: www.tbl2.com/IDP_comps.xls

[Orca]

you're awesome

[Argonauts]

That option #2 looks good.